Assessment Task – Tutorial Questions Assignment
Unit Code: HA3042
Unit Name: Taxation Law
Assignment: Tutorial Questions Assignment (Individual)
Due: Week 13 – Friday, 26th February, 2021
This assignment is designed to assess your level of knowledge of the key topics covered in this unit
Unit Learning Outcomes Assessed:
1. Identify the sources of taxation law and the framework in which taxation is administered
2. Identify various types of taxation including income tax, consumption taxes, goods and services tax, taxes
on capital and fringe benefits tax
3. Identify and apply the fundamentals of calculating the taxable income and tax payable for individuals and
4. Analyse the taxation issues associated with straight forward international transactions
5. Communicate knowledge of taxation law, through written and/or oral communication, and be able to
demonstrate critical thinking and legal analytical skills.
Each week students were provided with three tutorial questions of varying degrees of difficulty. The tutorial
questions are available in the Tutorial Folder, for each week, on Blackboard. The Interactive Tutorials are
designed to assist students with the process, skills and knowledge to answer the provided tutorial questions.
Your task is to answer a selection of tutorial questions from weeks 1 to 12 inclusive and submit these answers
in a single document.
The questions to be answered are:
Question 1 – Week 6 – Specific Deductions (7 marks)
In Year 1, Crocodile Pty Ltd has $600,000 of assessable income and $1,000,000 of deductions.
In Year 2, Crocodile has $300,000 of exempt income, $200,000 of assessable income and $500,000 of
In Year 3, Crocodile has $500,000 of assessable income, $200,000 of exempt income and $200,000 of
Advise Crocodile of its taxable income or tax loss in each year.
Question 2 – Week 8 – Fringe Benefits Tax (7 marks)
Samit borrowed money from his employer amounting to $15,000 on the 2nd September, 2019 because of an
emergency situation. His mother was unwell and she lives abroad. Samit needs to urgently send the money to
his parents. Because Samit is a good employee, his employer lent him the money with no interest.
Furthermore, on the 28th February, 2020 due to compassionate reasons shown by the company – his
employer – , the company decided that he was only required to repay $5,000. The employer is GST
Please advise Samit and his employer on the tax implications of the above transaction. Please refer to the
relevant Tax legislation and other appropriate sources, including cases, if required.
Question 3 – Week 12 – Transfer Pricing (7 marks)
Please refer to the direct quotation below from the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) website:
www.ato.gov.au for this question. Consider the following extract:
“Base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS) refers to the tax planning strategies used by multinational
companies to exploit gaps and differences between tax rules of different jurisdictions internationally. This is
done to artificially shift profits to low or no-tax jurisdictions where there is little or no economic activity.”
Question 3 (Cont’d) (7 marks)
Please discuss whether taxing “Revenue” instead of “Profit” will solve the Transfer Pricing issue. You must
elaborate your answer with appropriate analysis and justification.
Note – Please use the following four (4) steps to answer this question:
1. Identify the facts
2. Identify the relevant Tax Laws and cases or other key Tax sources
3. Apply the relevant laws and cases to the facts
4. Provide a conclusion
Question 4 – Week 6 – Capital Allowances (7 marks)
Butterfly Pty Ltd is a small business that utilizes the low value pool for its fixed assets for all its eligible
assets. All depreciable assets are 100% used for business purpose, and the closing low value as at 30 June
2019 was $6,250. Shown below in the table is the asset register for Butterfly Pty Ltd as at 30 June 2019.
Asset Cost Opening
Value Method Effective Life Decline in
This Period Closing
MacBook Pro 4,000 2,400 Diminishing
rate) 5 years 960 1,440
MacBook Air 1,300 1,300 Diminishing Value 3 years 450 850
Equipment 10,000 7,000 Prime Cost 10 years 1,000 6,000
Furnitures 1,200 1,080 Prime Cost 10 years 120 960
Note – Butterfly purchased a printer on 8 May 2020 for $750 and Butterfly also purchased a TV for the
meeting room on 2 June 2020 for $900
Calculate the “decline in value” of the depreciable assets that Butterfly can use as deductions for the 2019-
2020 income year.
Question 5 – Week 9 – Partnerships (11 marks)
Alastair is a retired programmer. His wife Fransiska is a retired accountant. Both wish to remain active in
their old age and they invest in a Doll shop that is to be managed by their daughter Sophie, who is aged 35.
The three of them form a partnership of three called “Wishful’s Doll Shop”.
Alastair and Fransiska contributed $90,000 each to fund the purchase of the shop.
The partnership agreement provides:
• Both Alastair and Fransiska are to receive interest at the rate of 10% pa on each of their capital contribution
• Sophie will receive a salary of $45,000 for the management of the shop, as well as superannuation
contributions of $9,000.
• A car will be leased by the business and provided to Carol. (100% used for business)
• All profits and losses are to be shared equally between the three partners.
The accounts for this income year show the following:
Sales (excluding GST) 590,000
Cost of goods sold 290,000
Interest on capital paid to Alasdair and Tracy 27,000
Salary to Carol 45,000
Superannuation to Carol 9,000
Lease payments on car (excluding GST) 8,500
Other deductible operating expenses (excluding GST) 34,000
Additional Information during the tax year:
– Alastair won a lottery for $100,000 (This is the first time Alastair bought a lottery) – In his spare time
Alastair also gives private tutoring for some programming languages.
– During the year he earned $15,000 from this activity
– Alastair lent $40,000 during the year as the business struggles in earlier months due to COVID- 19
lockdown. Alastair will receive 5% interest from the partnership on it.
With reference to the facts above:
a) Calculate the net income of the partnership.
b) What is the assessable income for Alastair during this tax year?
Question 6 – Week 11 – GST (11 marks)
Joshua Pty Ltd runs a furniture retailing business. During the tax year 19-20, Joshua provided customers with
various loan arrangements to finance the purchase of furniture.
Total expenses relating to the loan arrangements (specific loan calculation software and computers) totaled
$33,000 (inc. GST)
Joshua’s total expenses during the year (All expenses to run the business included the $33,000) were $2.2
million (inc. GST). Joshua Pty Ltd is registered for GST purposes.
Discuss Joshua’s Ability to claim the $3,000 Input Tax Credit?
The assignment will be submitted via Blackboard. Each student will be permitted only ONE submission to
Blackboard. You need to ensure that the document submitted is the correct one.
Holmes Institute is committed to ensuring and upholding Academic Integrity, as Academic Integrity is
integral to maintaining academic quality and the reputation of Holmes’ graduates. Accordingly, all
assessment tasks need to comply with academic integrity guidelines. Table 1 identifies the six categories of
Academic Integrity breaches. If you have any questions about Academic Integrity issues related to your
assessment tasks, please consult your lecturer or tutor for relevant referencing guidelines and support
resources. Many of these resources can also be found through the Study Skills link on Blackboard.
Academic Integrity breaches are a serious offence punishable by penalties that may range from deduction of
marks, failure of the assessment task or unit involved, suspension of course enrolment, or cancellation of
Table 1: Six Categories of Academic Integrity Breaches
Plagiarism Reproducing the work of someone else without attribution. When a student submits their own
work on multiple occasions this is known as self-plagiarism.
Collusion Working with one or more other individuals to complete an assignment, in a way that is not
Copying Reproducing and submitting the work of another student, with or without their knowledge. If a
student fails to take reasonable precautions to prevent their own original work from being copied, this may
also be considered an offence.
Impersonation Falsely presenting oneself, or engaging someone else to present as oneself, in an in-person
Contract cheating Contracting a third party to complete an assessment task, generally in exchange for money
or other manner of payment.
Data fabrication and falsification Manipulating or inventing data with the intent of supporting false
conclusions, including manipulating images.
Source: INQAAHE, 2020
If any words or ideas used the assignment submission do not represent your original words or ideas, you must
cite all relevant sources and make clear the extent to which such sources were used.
In addition, written assignments that are similar or identical to those of another student is also a violation of
the Holmes Institute’s Academic Conduct and Integrity policy. The consequence for a violation of this policy
can incur a range of penalties varying from a 50% penalty through suspension of enrolment. The penalty
would be dependent on the extent of academic misconduct and your history of academic misconduct issues.
All assessments will be automatically submitted to Safe-Assign to assess their originality.
For further information and additional learning resources please refer to your Discussion Board for the unit.